AgResults is a $152 million multilateral initiative that uses Pay-for-Results prize competitions to incentivize, or “pull”, the private sector to overcome agricultural market barriers by investing in innovative research and delivery solutions that improve the lives of smallholder farmers. At our core we are an experiential learning initiative, continuously building evidence on what works, and what does not, in using prize competitions to spur sustainable market change.Read more about our approach
Smallholder Farmers Reached
Current and Past Projects
Prize Funds Awarded (approx)
June 13, 2023
To mark the end of a successful second year, the AgResults Indonesia Aquaculture Challenge Project held a series of lessons learned and prize award events from June 6-9 in Jepara, Indonesia. The Pay-for-Results prize competition encourages competing businesses in Indonesia to deliver aerator and auto-feeder technologies to smallholder farmers. Four competitors, PT Multidaya Teknologi Nusantara (eFishery), PT Venambak Kail Dipantara, CV Republik Vannamei, and PT Bumi Wirasatraya Sejahtera, qualified for prizes with 537 sales and 3,650 rentals, winning a total of USD $159,101. In addition to sharing lessons learned, there were several technology trial and induction events and competitor selection for the upcoming year.
In Indonesia, AgResults is aiming to overcome multiple challenges in the country’s aquaculture sector related to feed cost, water quality, and quality of fish stocks—all of which have historically limited smallholder aquaculture practices’ efficiency, particularly via traditional ponds. This inefficiency not only limits productivity but also has an adverse impact on the environment and sustainability of fish farming. By increasing adoption of on-farm technologies such as feeders and aerators, the prize competition aims to strengthen value chain links and boost smallholder farmer income. In just two years, these benefits have started to emerge, particularly around increased efficiency in the use of feed.
"After a slow start to Year 1 of the competition, due largely to COVID-19 restrictions on movement and the resulting pandemic-induced economic downturn, we have seen significant improvement in competitor performance and smallholder farmer uptake of the technologies in Year 2,” said Kimya Nia of the AgResults Secretariat. “The goals for today’s event are to provide everyone with an update on lessons learned from this year of the competition and recognize and award four successful competitors for their performance.”
In Year 2, the four winning competitors sold 547 units and rented 3,650 units of technology to smallholder farmers in Java and outside Java, with the highest target of aquaculture commodities being tilapia and pangasius followed by vannamei shrimp and catfish.
Dr. Imam Musthofa Zainudin, Director of the Marine and Fisheries Program at Yayasan WWF Indonesia, said, "Increasing the productivity by smallholder farmers requires the support of various sectors involved in the aquaculture value chain, including the availability of high-quality seeds, aquaculture technology, technical assistance, and the availability of best aquaculture practice guidelines to support the continuity of aquaculture business and a healthy environment.”
This cross-sector perspective has positioned participating companies to improve their approach and grow their business.
“AgResults has helped us become a catalyst in accelerating the adoption of our auto-feeder by smallholder farmers,” said a representative from Competitor PT Multidaya Teknologi Nusantara (eFishery). “As our auto-feeder rentals have increased 4-5x from 200-500 units in Year 1 to 3,300 in Year 2, so has our impact in helping small farmers achieve intensification. We are growing together.”
More than 1,900 smallholder farmers have adopted aquaculture technologies to use resources more efficiently: Aerators can efficiently use water and land, auto-feeders can efficiently use feed. Beyond improving smallholder farmers’ productivity and income, these technologies strengthen the sector’s sustainability.
"As a recent start-up, we have faced a lot of challenges, but getting involved in this project has challenged us to improve our technology more quickly by connecting us to smallholder farmers across the country,” said a representative from PT Venambak Kail Dipantara, another competitor. “We plan to invest this prize money into the business to improve our aerators for Year 3.”
In the upcoming year, the competition aims to encourage even more companies and distributors to reach smallholder farmers to improve their use of innovative aquaculture technology and water quality management in Indonesia.
The Indonesia Aquaculture Challenge Project is part of AgResults, a $152 million collaborative initiative between the governments of Australia, Canada, the United Kingdom, the United States, the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, and the World Bank Group that uses prize competitions to incentivize the private sector to overcome market barriers and create lasting change. Under AgResults’ Pay-for-Results model, these competitions encourage actors to achieve predetermined results thresholds and quality for monetary prizes....
Increased demand for fresh milk in Tanzania presents a major opportunity for smallholder farmers – yet, they still have low productivity. What is holding smallholder farmers (SHF) back and can the private sector be a major actor in solving this challenge?
Tanzania’s dairy sector has sizable hurdles to overcome that are present across the full value chain. Approximately 97% of Tanzania’s dairy cattle are low yield breeds which constrains productivity for smallholder farmers. Other associated factors are the SHF's limited awareness and understanding of quality inputs, low accessibility to inputs, and the lack of accessible and effective extension and advisory services. These combined deficiencies have resulted in minimal use of productivity increasing inputs and therefore reduced outcomes.
The AgResults Tanzania Dairy Challenge Project was established to incentivize private sector input suppliers to raise awareness and educate SHF on the value of adopting productivity-increasing input bundles to enhance production and strengthen dairy-based livelihoods. Conventional, supply sided ‘push’ interventions that reward activities rather than results may take years before sustained market transformations occur. However, three years into the Tanzania Dairy Challenge Project, the Pay-for-Results ‘pull’ incentive approach has already made an impactful shift in the dairy input supplier model and market, strengthening SHF’s demand for improved inputs.
Through the prize structure, nine competing input suppliers are partnering with SHF, especially those in historically underserved areas, to supply them with input bundles and advisory services. Smallholder farmers now have access to quality inputs, receive proper training on their correct usage, and have expanded their knowledge of livestock management. Input bundles are also having a profound impact on dairy cattle health – productivity is dramatically rising and mortality is declining. Farmers can judge the impact of increased input usage on milk yield, fertility, and animal health, which is reinforcing the input supplier’s extension messages and advice.
The rapid returns SHFs are experiencing from using enhanced extension services has accelerated the shift to make improved input purchases the default. These factors secure the demands for inputs and reduce risks for input supplier businesses. Smallholder dairy farmers are now positioned to participate more fully in formal markets, due to the increased milk supply, improving their incomes and livelihoods.
The project spans four sales periods each lasting nine months (June to February) and is currently in the third sales period. The competition has awarded over $375k in monetary prizes to date, based on input sales made. Competitors have continued to strengthen their business practices each sales period, helping AgResults achieve its goals of increased input usage and greater dairy productivity. Impact is spreading rapidly and competitors are so encouraged by the results that they plan to continue these practices following the project's conclusion.
Read more about the Project's impacts in our Lessons Learned Article: https://agresults.org/learning/80-lessons-learned-article-pay-for-results-role-in-transforming-tanzania-s-dairy-input-supplier-model/file...
On January 25, project leadership hosted an information session with a wide range of 40 stakeholders which included fodder producers, Tanzania Agriculture Development Bank, government livestock ministry, private seed companies, technical assistance organizations, and NGOs to share project successes and introduce the new Fodder Incentive.
The success of Sales Period 3 has set a high bar for this upcoming sales period. During this time, there were 16 competitors that provided services to nearly 22,000 smallholder farmers (SHF) and delivered bundles of high-quality inputs to increase animal productivity, boost SHF income, and strengthen value chain relationships between dairy producers and the formal dairy sector.
Several competitors are anticipated to receive significant prizes for their efforts based on their ability to embrace and implement input-bundles, increase capacity, and expand their geographic footprints.
Aside from its early success and the competitors’ ability to scale impact each cycle, Sales Period 3 highlighted a clear opportunity for Sales Period 4 – an increase in fodder production. Limited availability of fodder was felt throughout the competition’s target regions, sparking AgResults to develop a new prize incentive to increase the supply of fodder in the competition and enable competitors to meet the requirement of the nutrition bundle as it launches into Sales Period 4.
After the success of its third sales period, the AgResults Tanzania Dairy Productivity Challenge Project has decided to tackle Tanzania’s fodder shortage through its promotion of private and parastatal engagement in the Fodder Incentive for the upcoming Sales Period 4.
The increased demand for hay, silage, and other dray matter coupled with unpredictable weather patterns has significantly reduced the supply of fodder in Tanzania’s coastal region and this was evidenced by the shortages of fodder in the current Tanzania Dairy Productivity Input Prize competition. To accelerate uptake of the nutrition bundle, AgResults donors instated an additional US$223k Fodder Incentive to incentivize supply-side production of dairy fodder and support market entry.
By participating in the Incentive, producers can win prize awards and help bolster the supply of fodder in the coastal area to support animal health, nutrition, and ultimately improved dairy productivity. We encourage you to apply and join us for a chance to win prizes and contribute to the development of a dairy sector in Tanzania. Should you have any questions or comments please direct them to NMrema@landolakes.org.
The deadline for receipt of applications for the Fodder Incentive, with all required signatures and certifications, is due no later than 1700 Hrs. EAT on February 3, 2023.
To learn more about submission details please visit: Request for Applications for Sales Period 4 Competitors and Producers for the AgResults Tanzania Challenge Project...
On behalf of the AgResults Tanzania Dairy Productivity Project (the “Project”), the Project Manager (PM) Land O’Lakes Venture37 invites your organization to participate in up to two prize mechanisms (1) an input bundle-based prize competition (“Input Bundle Competition” or “Competition”) and/or (2) a fodder prize incentive (“Fodder Incentive” or “Incentive”) through which the Project aims to test Pay-for-Results mechanism approaches to scaling up innovative technologies, tools, and approaches to increase dairy productivity by using improved inputs. Participants of the Competition (each a “Competitor” and collectively “Competitors”) and the Incentive (each a “Producer” and collectively the “Producers”) can work in independently of each other or in conjunction with each other, since the Competition and Incentive are different prize mechanisms. The Project will take place in the coastal region of Tanzania, and specifically the regions of Dar es Salaam, Pwani, Tanga, and Morogoro (excluding Kilombero and Ulanga districts).
Land O’Lakes Venture37 is calling for applications from potential Competitors who are established entities from the private, parastatal, and non-profit sectors to participate in the project for Sales Period 4. Competitors already engaged in previous sales period are required to re-apply as well.
Land O’Lakes Venture37 is also calling for applications from primary fodder producers from the private, parastatal, and non-profit sectors to participate in a newly instated Fodder Incentive. The Fodder Incentive is solely for sales period 4 and aims to accelerate smallholder farmer’s uptake of the nutrition bundle by incentivizing supply-side production of dairy fodder. Entities interested participating in both the Incentive and the Competition are required to apply to each prize mechanism.
The below RFA outlines the Project background, objectives, and rules, and includes two application forms, one for the Competition and another for the Fodder Incentive. In submitting an application, your organization consents to the RFA terms, including the application procedures and instructions.
Please note the deadline for receipt of applications for the Competition, with all required signatures and certifications, is due no later than 1700 Hrs. EAT on February 28, 2023. For the Competition, please indicate “Competitor RFA-AgResults Tanzania Dairy Productivity Project” in the subject line of the email or on the cover page.
The deadline for receipt of applications for the Fodder Incentive, with all required signatures and certifications, is due no later than 1700 Hrs. EAT on February 3, 2023. For the Fodder Incentive, please indicate “Producer RFA-AgResults Tanzania Dairy Productivity Project” in the subject line of the email or on the cover page.
Application documents must be submitted by email to AgResultsTanzania@gmail.com or by postal address to: Land O’ Lakes Venture37, P.O Box 10517 Dar es Salaam, or hand delivered to Veterinary Complex, 131 Nelson Mandela Road, Dar es Salaam.
The Project management team will review applications according to the criteria described herein. The applicants whose applications meet the selection criteria will be invited to participate in the competition.
We encourage you to submit an application and join us for a chance to win prizes and contribute to the development of a dairy sector in Tanzania. Should you have any questions or comments please direct them to NMrema@landolakes.com. We appreciate your timely response to this RFA and look forward to cooperating with you on this important project.
October 17, 2022
Vitamin A deficiency is a significant problem in Zambia: More than half of Zambian children ages 6 months to 5 years are deficient in Vitamin A, increasing their vulnerability to infections such as diarrhea, sight impairment, and other health problems. To combat this, in 2012, HarvestPlus, a multi-donor agricultural health and nutrition program, released three hybrid seed varieties of Pro-Vitamin A (PVA) maize high in beta-carotene. HarvestPlus aimed to target rural areas and promote the adoption of new PVA maize hybrids among smallholder farmers. Following these efforts by HarvestPlus, in 2014 AgResults launched a Pay-for-Results prize competition to (1) incentivize seed companies to produce and sell PVA maize seed to farmers and (2) incentivize millers to purchase PVA maize from farmers to mill and sell as PVA maize meal to urban and peri-urban consumers. However, myriad enabling environment challenges limited private sector participation, along with low consumer awareness and demand, so AgResults was forced to close the project in early 2018.
Although the AgResults project did not produce the intended results, it still laid the groundwork for later growth. Two seed companies that participated in the competition and were awarded monetary prizes continued to incorporate PVA maize into their operations in the following years. PVA maize is now a significant portion of their sales, and these actions have also encouraged competition for PVA maize seed production among from several other seed companies.
In the four years since the project ended, PVA maize seed sales have noticeably increased. A half dozen seed companies, including some of whom participated in the AgResults competition, have continued to sell PVA maize seed and improve their practices around PVA maize seed production. Their actions have been buoyed by increased demand for PVA maize, largely driven by government programs and non-governmental organizations through programs focusing on rural consumption. At the same time, as public opinion of PVA maize has improved among peri-urban and urban populations in Zambia, there has been a diversification of PVA maize products in the markets – no longer just maize meal but also snacks and other food products. Looking ahead, it will take a combination of efforts led by the government and by the private sector to determine the long-term future of the PVA maize market in Zambia.
A Lessons Learned article explores this narrative in more detail....