Results Based Incentive Structures for Agricultural Development

February 13, 2018

winners in Vietnam holding checks on a stage

Results-based incentive structures can offer donors an opportunity to enter into higher-risk markets that, if successful, could lead to significant development impact and more efficient use of donor funds. However, given that these mechanisms are relatively new, development practitioners are eager to understand how they can be applied to their own projects and what are best practices for designing and implementing them.

This was the resounding response the AgResults team received from approximately 20 World Bank staff on Wednesday, February 7, at a brown bag lunch hosted by the World Bank’s Agriculture Global Practice and coordinated by Chris Brett, Global Lead for Agribusiness and Value Chains. The AgResults team presented an overview of the program and how it was created to test these incentive structures as an option for donors and document what works and what doesn’t to achieve the program objectives.

After the overview presented by Rodrigo Ortiz, Secretariat Lead, the implementation team discussed two of their pilots: The Vietnam GHG Reduction Pilot was presented by Justin Kosoris.  This pilot is early in its implementation yet already giving valuable lessons learned.  The Nigeria Aflasafe™ Pilot was presented by Parasto Hamed. This pilot has been operating for over five years and continues to provide a wealth of learnings.  By presenting both pilots, the team highlighted various lessons that can occur in different stages of the design and implementation of this type of projects. Lessons from the pilots included:

The presentation was followed by a lively discussion that ranged from technical questions on how to verify the reduction of GHG emissions to the correct application of an agricultural input. Further technical discussions included how to identify the appropriate technology to promote using a results-based mechanism.

The discussion quickly turned from technical agriculture questions to the role these incentives play in the work of the World Bank Group. While funding structures of these mechanisms are still unclear (i.e. whether the World Bank can utilize a trust fund for these mechanisms or create new funds for them) these mechanisms are housed under the pay-for-results program (P4R) and are gaining momentum as an option for World Bank Staff to apply to their work. Earlier in that week, Jim Kim, the president of the World Bank, highlighted similar results-based mechanisms in a panel discussion on Maximizing Finance for Development, a high-level panel discussion on how to leverage private sector finance for development.

AgResults is a $122 million multi-donor initiative between the governments of Australia, Canada, the United Kingdom, the United States, and the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation to incentivize the private sector to overcome market barriers and develop solutions to food security and agricultural challenges that disproportionately affect people living in poverty. The World Bank Group acts both as the trustee and as a non-voting member of the Steering Committee of the program. 

Recent News & Blog Posts

A farmer holds up a bag of nutritious feed for her dairy cows.

How Pay-for-Results Paved the Way for Sustainable Dairy Production in Tanzania

July 15, 2024

The Tanzania prize competition transformed the way that dairy businesses in the country approach delivery of inputs and…

Farmer provides feed to dairy cow in Tanzania

Success Story: Best in Show in Tanzania

July 8, 2024

From 2020 - 2024, 24 business owners participated in the AgResults Tanzania Dairy Productivity Challenge Project, which was implemented…

Winners from the Indonesia aquaculture competition stand on stage

AgResults Recognizes Indonesia Aquaculture Competitor Achievements during Year 3 Award Ceremony

June 11, 2024

On June 4, winners from Year 3 of the Indonesia Aquaculture competition were recognized for their achievements. To…

agresults logo

Request for Proposals for Verifier Services for the FMD Vaccine Challenge Project

June 3, 2024

The Secretariat of AgResults (“Secretariat”) invites your organization to submit a proposal (“Proposal”) to provide verification services in…